Northern Health Campaigns Together action points and CHPI presentation

Vivek Kotecha of the Centre for Health and the Public Interest (CHPI) presentation with a sound and simple critique of the NHS England Five Year Forward View

NHS England Five Year Forward View – do the numbers add up?

Action points from the Northern HCT Meeting

Galvanisng Labour
1. Need to brief councillors re NHS developments – they don’t always have the info. ( KONP and 999 have briefings on ACOs) HCT paper carries useful info and examples where Councils have made a stand. These important to build
2. Pledges can be useful. Local elections will provide opportunity to put candidates on the spot.
3. Press for consistency between Composite 8 at national Conference and local policy making – blatant gap round
ACOs etc
4. Labour leadership needs pressure to give guidance. John Ashworth has spoken out but generally seems to need a rod up his back? Work on/with some good local Labour MPs where poss.
5. Where campaigners are in the Labour Party, get resolutions through local branches and Constituencies to put direct pressure on MPs and councillors
6. Attend and challenge at Board and Committee meetings. Health and Wellbeing crucial. Scrutiny Boards don’t always allow questions but can ask to speak or present case for Scrutiny. Community Committees are another route for the public to access their councillors.
7. Note not all areas have strong Labour groups. Have to work with politicians of other parties too!

1. Unions are working together. Need to work on more joined up activity with health workers, TUs and
2. Resistance to the imposition of wholly owned subsidies, currently for facilities staff, is urgent as many Trusts are
ploughing ahead with implementation.
3. Important to campaign for safe staffing. It shouldn’t be difficult to get the public on board with this. Need good,
clear info. Also need to make the links for NHS workers and try to get them more engaged with the broader campaignto save the NHS. Difficult because they are ground down by it every day.
4. Need to engage more young people which may mean doing things a bit differently – creative/ interesting/ media savvy?

Accountable Care Organisations
1. Getting the messages across to the public is difficult because of terminology. Materials produced need to translate
what is happening into simple, clear messages.
2. Need to explain some of the history with McKinsey et al to help people understand the long waves of planning for
3. Have to try to tackle the disconnect between what Labour Councillors are doing and LP policy
4. We have to make the economic arguments against “austerity” to challenge the “ there just isn’t enough money”

Campaigning Against Cuts and Closures
1. We need to build in an inclusive, open way and recognise that there is a critical mass to get significant shift
2. Also need to try to be to be patient – we’re in it for the long haul
3. Even small groups can generate lots of activitieswhich help to build the campaign
4. Need to get message across to the public that health care is a RIGHT , they are not getting the care they should but it CAN be delivered
5. Although Labour can be very supportive, we must reach out to ALL parties and remain pan political
6. Develop relationship with local media and local politicians
7. Develop local profiles in all your localities attending local events eg fetes, carnivals etc
8. Ensure the group is financially sound and that there is accountability at every level when money is being handled.
9. Draw in local NHS staff to the campaign and approach all their unions and staff associations
10. Engage with the local CCG’s and their farcical processes as information is key, especially the detail.
11. Can the group pursue a legal challenge? Try to get free legal advice and explore any potential legal loopholes.
12. Ensure local councils are forced to use their statutory scrutiny powers and where possible secure referral to the
Secretary of State

Demos /rallies:

Feb 24th Save Bolton NHS rally 12 noon Victoria Square
March 3rd Sheffield rally 3pm on Barkers Pool then demo being planned for 28th April
March 10th NE march and rally assemble 11.45 Framlington Place, next to RVI ,rally 12 at Monument
April 14th Yorks/ Northern HCT march , assemble 11.30 Leeds Art Gallery, march 12.15, short rally
May 12th National TUC demo for workers’ rights in London . Assemble Embankment 11am
June 30th NHS 70th Birthday demo in London, starts 12 noon


Join us for the Battle for the NHS – the People vs the Government, Leeds 22nd June

John Lister, founder member and national secretary of Keep Our NHS Public will give a round up of the attacks on the NHS- from Devolution and local cuts- to TTIP and privatisation. We will be focusing on what we can do locally to stop these attacks and save the NHS- free at the point of need.

WHEN 22nd June 19.00 – 21.00pm

WHERE Cosmopolitan Hotel, 2 Lower Briggate, LS1 4AE Leeds

Facebook event page:

NHS local news roundup

Leeds Public Health slashed

Seven months into the financial year the Department of Health has revealed that all local authorities will have their public health allocation slashed by 6.2 per cent this year. Council bosses in Leeds, who claim the city’s public health budget is already £6million short of what it should be, asked that their lack of funds be taken into account during a four-week consultation earlier this year.

Coun Lisa Mulherin, executive member for health, has accused the Government of “not paying attention to anything that was said” in going ahead with a straight percentage cut she claims will impact Leeds more than other areas.
The Department of Health claims a standard cut “causes the least disruption to services”. Having been tasked with saving £2.8m worth of cuts before the end of the financial year, the council has earmarked £2.2m of savings in areas like smoking cessation, winter wellbeing services, oral health and healthy schools work. Coun Mulherin said: “We knew the Government has complete contempt for local government but this shows complete contempt for the public as well and flies in the face of their attempt to protect all health services.” She continued: “They are not protecting the NHS they are cutting it directly through us.”

The move means the council still has £600,000 to find, while fears the cut will be made recurrent have stopped them renewing the contract of HIV support service BHA Leeds Skyline.

Sign the Skyline petition

NB Sarah Calkin in The Local Govt. Chronicle 4.11.15 notes The announcement this afternoon comes almost five months after the chancellor first revealed plans for the £200m cut and two months after a consultation on how the cut should be applied closed. Of the 152 LA’s affected, 81% responded to the consultation . The 6.2% cut was the DH’s preferred option for applying the cut, as they argued it would be the “simplest and most transparent option to implement”. It was backed by just a quarter of respondents. The most popular option amongst local authority respondents was to take a greater proportion of cut from those areas that receive more than their target allocation.   A further 13 local authorities advocated an alternative approach of making a flat cut per head of population, arguing this would be fairer and that under the DH preferred option, areas with a high proportion of the population from a black or minority ethnic background would suffer a greater impact.

Leeds based Pharmacy2U scandal

Pharmacy hit with £130,000 fine for selling on patient data in Pulse 20.10.15
A major online pharmacist has been fined £130,000 by the information commissioner for selling on the data of more than 20,000 patients to secondary marketing companies, which is likely to have resulted in patients having ‘suffered financially’.
The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) today fined Pharmacy 2U for failing to inform customers of their intention to sell on their names and postal addresses through an online marketing list company, and for selling it without consent, in contravention of the Data Protection Act. While the company says medical details were not passed on, it has not been able to notify the customers affected because it ordered the ‘certified destruction’ of their names when the breaches came to light.

The companies who bought Pharmacy 2U customer data, include a health supplements company that has been cautioned for misleading advertising and unverified health claims. It also included an Australian lottery company under investigation by Trading Standards and which an ICO investigation said  ‘appeared to have deliberately targeted elderly and vulnerable individuals, and it is likely that some customers will have suffered financially as a result of their details being passed on’.
The breaches were partly identified as part of a Daily Mail investigation into list marketing companies targeting vulnerable individuals.

The company ‘sincerely apologised’ for the breach, and said that as soon as it was made aware of the breach it ‘stopped the trial selling of customer data and made sure that the information that had been passed on was securely destroyed’………
ICO deputy commissioner David Smith said: ‘Patient confidentiality is drummed into pharmacists. It is inconceivable that a business in this sector could believe these actions were acceptable.

Some time ago, we mentioned that there was an electronic link from the GP surgeries to Pharmacy2U and that could prove to be a problem. Well, it seems to be more imminent than we thought. I was reading the entrepreneur’s magazine “Growing Business” and what should I find, but an article about the company and the fact that “the founders (of Pharmacy2U) found themselves on the brink of dramatic expansion in a market worth £10bn”. (A copy of the article is available here). In this article, the founders state that they were chosen by the government to “lead a two year NHS pilot project to develop an electronic prescription system to monitor what is being prescribed and dispensed”.
They go on to say that at the moment they are connected to 250 surgeries but they are hoping to roll that out to the 6000 surgeries that they can link to directly, i.e. through the EMIS computer software.
As EMIS has a just below 20% stake in Pharmacy2U, you can see how the system will benefit both parties to the exclusion of all other community pharmacies. A GP simply has to ask a patient if they want their medicines delivered, and if they say yes, he will press a button on his EMIS computer and the script will be relayed automatically to Pharmacy2U.

If you want to avoid this happening in your area, you should sign your patients up to your collection service and warn your LPC and LAT of this danger that could wipe out the present community pharmacy network.The Company also offers GP consultations and some treatments.

Bootham Park Hospital: sudden closure leaves patients vulnerable by Nicola Slawson Guardian 1.10.15
Bootham Park hospital, part of the Leeds and York Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, was ordered to close on Wednesday after an unannounced inspection by the Care Quality Commission (CQC) on 9 September found it was unfit for purpose and that patients were at “significant risk of harm” .

Rachael Maskell, MP for York central, is demanding an inquiry after CQC inspectors gave staff just five days to close Bootham Park Hospital following the inspection. “The risk to patients is very evident. I think what’s happened is a massive national scandal. It’s as political as much as clinical,” Maskell said. The situation, Maskell said, is a “complete mess”.

Bootham Park had been the subject of an earlier CQC inspection in January that called for significant improvements to the 18th century hospital building. Despite nine months passing, the mandated work, which included removing ligature points which represented a suicide risk, had not been undertaken. Part of the ceiling fell on inspectors during the inspection.
There has been widespread confusion and worry among the 400 outpatients served by Bootham – some of whom had appointments there on a daily basis – about where and when their next appointments will be. The jobs of the hospital’s 300 staff are also in jeopardy. Of the 30 inpatients who were in the emergency admission wards at Bootham at the time of the closure, eight were transferred 50 miles away to Middlesbrough and 15 patients were discharged to home treatment. Two were transferred to a recovery unit in York. With no provision for acute mental health care in York, patients will have to be taken out of the area for inpatient treatment.

Problems at Bootham Park were first highlighted in a CQC inspection which took place in December 2013. The report stated that it did not meet the standards for safety. Following this, a major investigation was launched after 74-year-old Sheila Jane Rusholme was found dead hanging in her room in the hospital. The trust later admitted a ligature point should have been removed earlier. Improvements were made that year, including the removal of several ligature points, at a total cost of £1.76m, but in January 2015 the CQC visited again and expressed concern about safety on some of the wards. “The question is what on earth has happened when serious risk to patients was raised in January and we are in September and this reparation hasn’t happened,” said Maskell.

Responsibility for both the hospital and the building is shared between commissioners, providers, regulators and infrastructure bodies. The building is owned by NHS property services but English Heritage also has a say in work carried out on the Grade I-listed building, meaning major redesign was not possible.“This is where the politics comes in ……. They’re all pointing the blame at each other,” said Maskell.

The situation at Bootham was further complicated after Vale of York clinical commissioning group (CCG) recently chose to transfer York’s mental health services from Leeds and York Partnership NHS Trust to Tees, Esk and Wear NHS Trust, which was due to take place on Thursday. The decision sparked a complaint to Monitor, the health sector regulator, and accusations of a conflict of interest. This argument was going on during the nine-month period when the safety improvements should have been taking place. Roy Lilley, a former NHS Trust chairman, believes the real problem is that none of the bodies involved are owning the problem. He said: “There is no-one, between the CQC, the CCG, the trusts, Monitor and PropCo, who come out of this with any credibility at all. “What it shows is that there is no strategic overview in the NHS anymore. Each of these organisations is autonomous, so no one can bang their heads together and make them do anything and in consequence, the loser is the public and users of the service. I think it’s a disgrace.” …..

Heated meeting examines what caused Bootham Park Hospital to close,  The Press York 20.10.15
A meeting of the Health and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee has tonight heard from the NHS organisations involved in the closure of Bootham Park Hospital. Senior managers said significant progress has been made since the closure of the hospital and plans are underway to provide an interim psychiatric unit in York – which could potentially be a 24 bed unit at Peppermill Court off Huntington Road – with the long term objective of opening a new, purpose built hospital in 2019.
The meeting was told the Care Quality Commission (CQC) carried out an unannounced inspection at the hospital in September after a series of further concerns about Bootham Park Hospital had been brought to their attention. Jenny Wilkes, of the CQC, said these included concerns about the “stench of dead rats under the building”, water leaks and concerns about staffing levels. When inspectors went into the building they found serious concerns including the heat of the water, which was hot enough to scald patients, that patients were not in clear lines of sight, the risk of hanging from ligature points and possible Legionella risks in the water supply. Vale of York Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG), Leeds and York Partnership NHS Foundation Trust (LYPFT), new provider Tees and Esk Wear Valleys Trust (TEWV), and NHS Property Services said it would have no objections to a formal inquiry, and councillors agreed this would be something they would consider. Leeds council bosses attack ‘sham’ consultation as £2.8million public health cut confirmed Jonathan Brown in the Yorkshire Evening Post writes:


TTIP trail today in Leeds

Take a break from shopping and join WDM, Leeds Uni students who have set up a trail across the centre of Leeds with different locations with each area affected/ threatened by  the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership and learning about Leeds local history along the way:

11.15 The Corn Exchange –  trade  

11.45 Kirkgate market – food , local businesses

12.15  Briggate  – disputes  ( then brief lunch break)

1.15 Leeds Town Hall – democracy

2pm Millennium Square and Civic Hall – democracy and workers’ rights

2.45 Infirmary Street – health / NHS

3.15 City Square , Mill Hill Chapel, and Trinity – dissent